Outline
for the First Term Paper
1.
Introduction
a. Movies
are awesome, mostly because they have a lot of cool stunts.
b. But
to be awesome they usually have to break a lot of rules of physics to pull it
off.
c. Spider-Man
is a fun example to look at and each cinematic version has some “problem scenes”
to address.
2.
Spider-Man (2002) and the bridge scene
a. Spidey
sling-shot launching himself towards the bridge and smoothly swinging through
it with no problem
b. He
shouldn’t be able to make that first web contact so smoothly without any
dramatic change in force
c. They
got around it with how fast he was moving and the motion blur
d. He
should have been flung clear out of the bridge and would have to last-second
correct with a web-shot back into it followed by some more swings to get his
momentum under control.
3.
Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014) and Gwen’s
death
a. Spidey
tries to save Gwen with a web-grab while they are in mid-fall. Spidey stops his
fall by grabbing a beam while simultaneously stopping Gwen’s fall with his
other hand’s web-shot. She dies from the force of her head hitting the floor
from the sudden stop even when she’s suspended above it.
b. Could
Gwen’s death have been prevented if Spidey caught her with a web-shot sooner in
the air? Eeeehhhhhhh probably not…
c. Even
if he did manage to catch her a few feet more above the ground, the sudden stop
still could have been enough to still break her neck from the sudden stop in
the air due to whiplash.
d. The
only way to prevent it would have been to either aim for a different part of
her that wouldn’t affect her head so violently (like her arm…which would have
been dislocated, but she’d still be alive), or more ideally caught her with his
own hands and THEN used webbing to stop their fall or slowing their fall more
gradually.
4.
Spider-Man Homecoming (2017) and stopping
the elevator
a. Spidey
stops an elevator filled with his classmates from falling to their demise. He
stops it by shooting a web to the ceiling of the shaft and pulling against it
from inside the elevator with his feet against the elevator’s ceiling.
b. The
abrupt stop doesn’t seem to affect the other occupants too much, just
stumbling.
c. The
speed of the elevator should have been enough to at least force them onto the
ground instead of standing up on foot.
d. It
would have been excusable if they were holding onto any railing or something to
brace themselves.
5.
Conclusion
a. Inertia
is a crucial element when it comes to depicting Spider-Man’s impressive feats
of skill, so it can be tricky to try and walk the tightrope between amazement
and believability.
b. Most
of these issues could be solved with either minimal or super specific tweaks,
but ultimately telling a story and causing more wow is what inspires these
scenes to go the way they do.
c. Despite
these gaps in logic, these films are still fun and that is the whole point of
watching them, to be amazed.
Comments
Post a Comment